You are not logged in.

× General Club Chat

The place for general chat about St Neots Cycling Club

Knee Pain Advice

  • Muchee
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • Junior Member
  • Junior Member
More
11 Sep 2012 17:21 #1 by Muchee
Knee Pain Advice was created by Muchee
I have been having some knee pain which hasn't got any worse but is always hot and quite painful after high intensity rides.

Firstly, can anyone recommend a good Phisio locally, secondly anyone know a good bike fit centre and lastly any other advice would be greatly appreciated excluding responses like "man-up!" :S

Please Log in to join the conversation.

More
11 Sep 2012 18:16 #2 by alec
Replied by alec on topic Re: Knee Pain Advice
Usual disclaimer - I'm no physio etc etc so take what I say with a pound of salt, but in my experience knee pain is caused most frequently by cleat alignment (some prefer parallel some toe-in and some toe-out - I am in-line on left foot and toe-out on my right foot: diagnosed by sitting on the edge of a table and letting my legs just dangle in a relaxed way - my right foot naturally turns out and my left foot doesn't - I hasd major problem with my right knee before I figured that out; do your cleats have float?); or by saddle height (usually too low). Others have reported pronation (ie whether your foot rolls towards the outside edge) or supination (towards the inside edge) as a factor. Can't help on the physio or bike fit, sorry.

Senior Shouting Officer

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • Muchee
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • Junior Member
  • Junior Member
More
11 Sep 2012 18:19 #3 by Muchee
Replied by Muchee on topic Re: Knee Pain Advice
Thanks alec, I think you could be right just finding it difficult to get the correct alignment. I have keo grey cleats with a 4.5 degree float. I think the red cleats have 9+ degree float. Maybe they will help?

Please Log in to join the conversation.

More
11 Sep 2012 18:27 #4 by alec
Replied by alec on topic Re: Knee Pain Advice
Well more float could help but some people don't like it because it feels weird to have your feet swivelling around. Even with float, I have to align the cleat to allow my right foot to toe-out or I get serious ACL pain and inflammation over longer rides. Try the sitting on a table trick to see how your feet naturally align. Otherwise, if that sort of thing doesn't work, a bike fit is probably the next step (needs to be with someone who really knows what they are doing).

Senior Shouting Officer

Please Log in to join the conversation.

More
11 Sep 2012 23:09 #5 by feef
Replied by feef on topic Re: Knee Pain Advice
Where in the knee do you get the pain? Cleats are the most common reason, but there are other causes due to patella tracking or sheer forces which can be affected by saddle position and crank length.

In some cases, lateral displacement of the knee can cause pain, although for many that sort of movement is entirely natural and pain free.

Also consider what your foot and ankle are doing when you ride, you could be suffering excessive dorsiflexion

There's quite a range of what we do with our ankles when we pedal. Toes can point up or down and the range of ankle movement between the top and bottom of the stroke can range from -10° to +30°. ‘Normal’ ankle behaviour would be to undergo a small amount of dorsiflexion as the power is applied, followed by approx. 20° of plantarflexion as the leg is fully extended.

High levels of ankle dorsiflexion can cause large knee displacements, usually when the cranks are approximately horizontal and loads are at their highest. Under high efforts, the heel may also stay low around the bottom of the stroke, stretching the hamstrings and calf muscles that attach behind the knee.

Sometimes, this excessive dorsiflexion is due to collapsed arches and so insoles with arch support can help that too.

One of the less common reasons is vertical offset, but I'm only really familiar with that for very skinny riders where the combined width of the BB, cranks and pedals and spindles means the angle between their legs varies proportionately more between the top and bottom of the pedal stroke than with someone of a normal build. It's not very common, but interesting to consider.

As Alec says, tho, the first and most common reason is cleat misalignment, but just bear in mind that it's not the be all and end all. If you're still getting pain after you're sure the cleats are right, then consider some of these other possible reasons.

When a passenger of the foot, hooves in sight, tootel the horn trumpet melodiously

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.138 seconds
Go to top